Start writing a post

Christopher Columbus was a fraud. Can we stop celebrating his legacy now?

The guy gets a federal holiday, but what did he actually accomplish?

Christopher Columbus was a fraud. Can we stop celebrating his legacy now?

Christopher Columbus statue

Photo by Blaz Erzetic on Unsplash

When I was a little, I would get extremely excited for the second Monday in October, primarily because it offered an additional day off from school. Yes, I'm consciously aware of how ignorant that sounds. But like most children, I was unaware of the dark history surrounding Columbus Day, primarily because Christopher Columbus was considered as a great dude.

Throughout my elementary school youth, we were taught Christopher Columbus was an upstanding citizen, who not only discovered America, but provided Native Americans with prosperous opportunities. But with most American history, the truth isn't as clear and picturesque as it often seems and the story surrounding Columbus is no different.

He didn't actually discover America

Let's get one thing straight so there's no confusion moving forward; Christopher Columbus didn't discover America. In fact, Columbus never set foot in North America. A Norse explorer by the name of Leif Eriksson was believed to have been the guy who first set foot in North America...500 years before Columbus was even born.

Columbus explored the Central and South American coasts, but never actually reached North America.

He was a brutal slave owner

For those who thought Columbus was a genteel man, who provided Native Americans with an abundance of opportunities, think again. When Columbus landed on an unknown Caribbean island in 1492, the international slave trade was beginning to grow. During that time, Columbus and his men enslaved numerous natives within the West Indies, subjecting them to immense cruelty and violence.

Columbus forced natives to work for profits, eventually sending thousands of peaceful Taino "Indians" from the island of Hispaniola to Spain to be sold. Hispaniola, or Spanish La Española if you want to get really technical, is the second largest island of the West Indies. It lies within the Greater Antilles, in the Caribbean Sea and is divided politically into the Republic of Haiti (west) and the Dominican Republic (east).

Being that Columbus was governor and viceroy of the Indies, he inflicted strict authority over what is now the Dominican Republic. When the natives rebelled, Columbus enacted cruel orders in which many natives were killed. To prevent further retaliation, and send a message to natives, Columbus ordered their dismembered bodies to be paraded through the streets.

So... why do we continue celebrating him again?

To honor Italian-American heritage, the first Columbus Day was celebrated on October 12th, 1792, in New York. In 1937, President Franklin D. Roosevelt proclaimed October 12th a national holiday to commemorate Columbus's legacy. It wasn't until 1972 when the holiday was changed to the second Monday of every October. So I guess we can thank our 32nd President for the federal holiday.

It wouldn't be the first time a U.S. President has made a mistake.

So there you have it, a brief explainer on why Columbus Day should be abolished. In fact, let's just celebrate Indigenous Peoples Day, or Native American Day instead. It's ten times better than having a federal holiday commemorating the legacy of a brutal, Italian slave owner who didn't actually discover America

I'm pleading for pop culture to stop playing OCD for laughs

Perhaps the time has come to re-evaluate how we portray OCD in films and TV series.

Melvin Udall in As Good as it Gets

I've had Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) since I was a child and I'm now in my early 40s. For all of this time, I have felt like I should be apologizing for it.

It's like this invisible phantom that engulfs one in fear and doubt and brings dark clouds to a shiny day at the park. The sense of guilt has always followed me due to the disorder being a part of my everyday life. For whenever I would try to talk about it to a friend or a relative, to explain a certain lifestyle choice, to touch upon its debilitating nature, I've often been looked at funny in return.

Keep reading... Show less

The first time I felt 'the fear' and the ugly truth about girlhood

Name-calling and rumours can take a big toll on a young teenager

It's somewhat amusing that people get struck by "the fear" the day after a big night out. "The fear" generally refers to a feeling of anxiety over your actions the previous night. What sort of embarrassing things did you do while intoxicated? In other words, "the fear" is really a light-hearted way of discussing anxiety.

Admittedly, I have used the phrase "the fear" plenty of times – laughing at pictures of myself and my friends dancing stupidly or realising I over-shared something silly with someone. But what about the first time I felt "the fear"?

Keep reading... Show less
#StartTheConversation by joining us on

Join our new platform for free and your post can reach a huge audience on Indy100 and The Independent join